Choosing a safe crib mattress is a huge decision and this can be equally confusing for new parents too.
This is essential to provide safe and comfortable bedding so that they can have sound sleep.
We all know how newborns and infants spend most of their time sleeping.
These long sleeping hours play an important role in their physical and psychological development.
To sleep without interruption, they need firm and solid bedding on their crib.
Finding an affordable, durable and good quantity bedding can sound like a tough job. But it really isn’t.
We have reviewed 15 best crib mattresses to help you out here.
What Are the Types of Crib Mattresses?
Based on the filling of them, these crib mattresses are classified into many types.
These are almost similar to that of adult mattresses except few features.
Basically there are three types of crib and toddler bed mattresses. Let us see them one by one.
First one is spring mattresses. These are strong, durable and provide a stable back for the bedding.
They have coils or spring inside at the bottom of the bedding which gives proper shape to the mattresses.
Over these coils, there is foam, cotton or any type of spongy material to form the cushion.
These types of mattresses are quite inexpensive and have a long life time too.
But they are also comparatively heavy weight than others due to the additional components.
These mattresses are most suitable for cribs as they have solid back which is needed for baby’s bone/physical development.
The next one is foam mattresses which are very commonly used and available in stores.
They contain a dense layer of foam inside which would probably be of the material polyurethane.
These are safe to use on your baby’s crib as long as they are firm and sturdy.
There are also double sided mattresses which you can use for your babies both during infant and toddler phase.
These mattresses have firm bedding on one side suitable for infant and soft bedding on the other side for toddlers.
What Are the Ideal Characteristics of an Infant Bed?
The material should be non toxic and should not have any chemicals as they can trigger allergic reactions.
The top layer should be firm and solid enough to not cause suffocation to the little babies sleeping over.
Firm mattresses are best than the normal soft ones as they doesn’t compress and suffocate the baby.
It must have a water proof layer at the top otherwise you will have to use a mattress protector.
It should be of right size as that of crib. There shouldn’t be long gap left between mattress and crib.
Weight of the mattress shouldn’t be high as you have to take it out often to clean and change sheets.
Now let us dive into our curated list of 15 best crib mattresses and their detailed reviews.
Our Top Picks Of Best Affordable Crib Mattresses
#1. Dream On Me 3″ Sunset Extra Firm Portable Crib Mattress
This crib mattress from ‘Dream on Me’ fits best in your standard crib and is extra-firm as the name suggests.
They have manufactured this with high quality ingredients that are phthalates and lead free and has an hypo allergenic cover.
It has 3 inches of thickness and is very easy to clean and spread this on daily basis.
The top layer is water proof and keeps the dirt, smell and development of bacteria at bay.
They use laminated stain and water resistant cover at the top which keeps the mattress odor and build-up safe.
It resists stain and odor and doesn’t let them penetrate in which helps you cleaning up mess easily.
You also get 30 days of warranty and reliable customer service who is ready to answer your queries anytime.
This product meets all the safety and flammability standards to ensure safe and durable bedding for your baby.
Get this today to offer premium and comfortable bedding to your newborn.
#2. Dream On Me 112 Coil Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress
This standard style grey mattress is from the same ‘Dream On Me’ brand and is Green guard gold certified product.
It has triple laminated mattress cover which is also strain and odor resistant which prevents leakage and mold formation.
This has a hypo allergenic cover and foam insulated layer and has lock stitched water proof binding.
This feature increases the strength and durability of the product.
You also get one month of warranty and easy replacement/return if you have any concern over the product bought.
This is a slumber spring coil mattress in order to provide rock solid support to your infant while sleeping.
This is a light weight mattress that has interwoven and heat tempered steel coils which offer more durability to this.
It has protective polyuerethane wrap on both the sides that offers a plush sleeping body and offers ultimate support.
It also has a layer of fire blocker inside which prevents accidental damages and safeguards baby too.
#3. Big Oshi Portable/Mini Crib Mattress
This is a 3 inch thick mini crib mattress from Big Oshi and is best for portable cribs.
They have this available in multiple sizes and for multiple purposes, that is for a bassinet, play pen etc.
This has orthopedic foam which offers gentle support and balance and optimal comfort for your sleeping baby.
It has hypo allergenic, 100% vinyl cover that prevents the mattress from forming mold, mildew and bad smell.
Since it has waterproof layer at the top, it prevents leakage and spill getting into the bed and spoiling it.
It is easy to clean this too. You can just clean this with warm water and cotton cloth.
Apart from water proof layer, this also has fire blocking layer too which meets safety standards and regulations.
Mattress holds its shape for long time and has great durability and fits as per the size dimensions mentioned.
There is three year warranty available for the product too.
#4. LA Baby Waterproof Portable/Mini Crib Mattress
This award-winning crib mattress is from LA baby brand and offers firm and great support to your growing baby.
It is a mini mattress that fits mini and portable cribs easily.
It has two inches of thickness and has a tear-resistant capacity that fits any mini-sized crib.
The outer layer of the mattress is waterproof with a vinyl layer that is easy to clean with wiping.
This layer is also anti-microbial, nontoxic, and hypoallergenic which keeps dirt and mold away from this.
You can use this as a replacement mattress also for a short time when your main mattress is out for drying.
Since the thickness is low, it’s easy to fold and store when it is not in use or while cleaning.
Pricing is great for the quality and durability of the product and it is also long-lasting.
Users are also happy with the product, quality, and pricing and have stated that it is reliable and useful.
#5. Naturepedic Organic Crib Mattress
This is a perfect organic crib mattress available out there that is made of natural and organic cotton.
Though it is a little expensive than others, it has organic cotton fabric and filling and is GOTS certified.
It is also made a safe and green guard certified.
Made in the USA, this is light in weight and is flame-retardant, and doesn’t have latex or PU Foam.
It has a 360-degree waterproof surface which is very pure and food grade.
This doesn’t have any water-repelling chemicals or flame retardants used but made with food-grade materials.
This has comfortable fitting in any type of standard-sized cribs and it is easy to flip the bed.
The layers inside the mattress are few layers of organic cotton coated with non-GMO sugarcane.
It is easy to clean this bed with just a cotton cloth and warm water or soap solution.
They have considered the safety of your children as their first priority and have provided excellent features based on your needs.
#6. Delta Children Twinkle Stars Fiber Core Crib and Toddler Mattress
This is a nontoxic crib mattress from delta children’s brand that is free from harmful materials and chemicals.
It is made in the USA and comes with a limited seven-year warranty.
They have mentioned the size dimensions and it easily fits in any standard size cribs. It is six inches thick.
This has gotten a certificate from a green-gold guard for using lower chemical exposures and helping in maintaining a healthy environment.
This is a dual-sided bed that you can use when your infant becomes a toddler just by flipping it.
And both sides have a waterproof vinyl layer too.
The top layer of the bed is strong and firm and is ideal to use for newborns and infants.
It has a vinyl coated waterproof layer at the top to not let in spills, urine, or spit ups.
It is light in weight which helps in changing the sheet easily by flipping it and changing the sides.
Square corners of the bed ensure a snug and secure fit in the crib and fit well.
#7. Graco Premium Foam Crib and Toddler Mattress
This is one of the best rated and recommended crib mattresses by many parenting blogs and magazines.
This is the only crib mattress that comes with a removable, water-resistant outer cover which is washable and reusable.
You can both hand wash and machine wash it for cleaning purposes and can hang dry it in sun.
This mattress cover is made of 100% polyester and catches up water, spills, and urine before getting in.
The mattress contains premium quality breathable foam inside that offers rigid support at the top.
It is free from lead, mercury, phthalates, and other flame retardant objects that are potentially harmful.
This product is green guard gold certified and meets all ASTM, CPSC standards, and federal flammability standards too.
This mattress fits both the standard-sized crib and toddler bed snugly and offers firm support at the top.
You get a six-year limited warranty with this product backed by 24/7 customer service.
#8. Colgate Eco Classica III Dual Firmness Crib Mattress
This is one of the premium quality mattresses from the house of Colgate kid’s mattress collections.
They come in three styles classica, eco classic, zen baby 2 stages, and zen baby hybrid 2 in 1.
And this one is an eco classic model.
They have made this product without flame retardants, ozone depleters, formaldehyde, heavy metals and it has low VOC emission rate.
It is certified and tested for its best quality and durability and users have vouched for its performance.
The waterproof cover is very soft and provides a comfortable base and bedding for your baby.
This layer keeps the bedding dry and keeps the baby safe from bacterial infections or wetness.
This is a six-inch thick mattress and is orthopedic too.
It is green guard certified and CertiPur US certified and is compliant with CPSIA and federal state flammability requirements.
This is light in weight and is portable too. So you can easily change sheets or put away to dry.
#9. Newton Baby Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed
Let us see another great crib mattress from Newton brand which is pure, washable and recyclable.
They have made this with hypo allergenic material which cannot irritate or cause allergies to your baby.
This is a dual-sided bed and has firm infant bedding on one side and soft toddler bed on other side.
It is available in four cute colors which are sunrise pink, grey, blue and white.
The whole material is 100% washable and its easy to dry them too. This is one of its best features.
It is also one of the award winning and pediatrician’s recommended crib mattress brand.
This is made of 100% pure and organic cotton and has no foam, springs, glue or allergens.
It has temperature regulating feature inside which prevents the bed from getting overheated.
Usually this over heating causes sweaty back in babies and disturbs them from their sleep.
With this add on feature, now your baby can have uninterrupted sleep.
#10. Moonlight Slumber Dual Sided Baby Crib Mattress
This is one of the affordable, most recommended and most rated crib mattresses available in Amazon.
You can use this on both sides and both sides has firmness which is ideal for newborns, infants and toddlers.
This is hypo allergenic and it is easy to clean this as this is purely washable.
It has used zero flammable materials and is toxic free. It has low impact on air due to low VOC.
Moonlight Slumber Dual Sided Baby Crib Mattress is eco friendly and has plant based foam layer.
This has used medical grade fabric and has a waterproof and durable stretch knit fabric.
With its safely sewn seams, this is bug and dust mite resistant and this safeguards your baby the most.
It has squared and cornered edges to fit into the crib perfectly.
This five inches bed is wrapped using woven fire barrier and then later covered with a medical grade water-resistant layer.
This bedding is comfortable and firm for your growing baby and light on your pockets as well.
#11. Sealy Baby Soybean Foam-Core Toddler & Baby Crib Mattress
This ultra firm and comfy crib mattress is from sealy baby and it is for both infants and toddlers.
The core of the high density foam is made with organic and bio degradable soy beans that offer good firmness.
It is so light weight that its total weight is less than 9 lbs. hence its easy to lift them.
Both the water proof cover and the foam is hypo allergenic and totally safe for your baby.
The top layer is water/strain resistant layer which is made of reinforced, lock-stitched material which prevents liquid getting in.
It also has a cotton wrap over that to give soft top layer for your baby.
All the corners of the bed are squared to make them fit well in your crib.
This is an award winning brand and it is also certi Pur and green guard gold certified for lower VOC.
#12. My First Crib Mattress
This is another good quality, plush and hypoallergenic standard crib mattress from ‘my first crib mattress’ brand.
This is a five inches foam mattress that fits any standard sized crib and is free from harmful, toxic materials.
Since the material is hypoallergenic, it prevents allergic reactions and infections and is mite and insects proof too.
This is a tested and certified product and complies and exceeds all the standards set by ASTM and CPSC.
It doesn’t have any flammable objects or harsh chemical sprays and is free from mercury, lead, and phthalates.
The outside waterproof cover is removable and 100% washable. You can both machine wash and hand wash it.
This product meets all standards both in terms of sizing and fit and is not using chemicals or flammable substances.
#13. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress
This lightweight and durable crib mattress is from safety 1st brand and is suitable for standard-sized crib.
It is lightweight and weighs around 50lbs. it is of 5 inches thickness and has 10 year limited warranty.
This product has gotten green guard gold certification for its low chemical emission and doesn’t spoil indoor air quality.
It has even gotten women’s choice award for America’s most recommended product for best crib mattress.
The core of the bedding is made with high density thermo bonded fiber core and it offers solid support.
The outer surface of the bed has 100% vinyl water proof cover that you can clean with a wipe.
This is a two sided mattress with extra firm bedding on one side and slightly cushiony side on other side.
As the name of the brand says, they consider safety of your baby as their first priority and made this.
#14. Milliard Crib Mattress
This is another great crib mattress from Milliard brand that has gotten many positive reviews and satisfactory comments.
It is a dual-sided mattress which has a softer side for toddlers and firm side on the other for infants.
This makes it perfect to use throughout their growing phase from their crib to toddler bed.
It has a washable and water resistant cover that is made of 100% cotton which is safe for your baby.
It doesn’t shrink or get displaced and stays in place when your baby moves here and there.
This is both green guard and certiPur US certified for using non toxic and no harmful materials.
The core of the bed has firm and soft memory foam and also has a woven and non-toxic fire barrier.
With 100% natural cover and safe ingredients used for bedding, this is a great choice to welcome your newborn.
#15. Official Amazon Exclusive NapYou Comfort Crib Mattress
This crib mattress is from Nap You brand and is one of the Amazon’s exclusively sold products.
The top layer of the bed is firm and offers better support to your growing baby.
It is easy to clean the top layer of the bed as it is water proof and prevents spills from getting inside.
And with perfectly sewn edges, it saves your bed from forming molds and insects inside.
This is a 5.5 inches bed that fits any normal and standard sized cribs and toddler beds too.
This product is CertiPur US certified for using safe and non toxic ingredients to manufacture this.
It is a dual sided bed which has firm side on one for infant and other side is little cushioned.
Crib mattress is an essential investment that you do for your arriving baby and it should be of good quality.
Getting a comfy, firm and durable mattress will keep your baby safe, comfortable and help them getting better sleep.
There are lots of affordable, premium quality mattresses available out there for standard and mini cribs.
Finding the right one for your baby is not a tough job if you know the parameters that you have to look out for.
And this article can help you in educating yourself about these and give you a clear idea about crib mattresses.